
I know that chances of hearing back from Gettleman (NYTimes correspondent for East Africa) are slim, but decided to write to him anyways. This is what I said:
Hi there Jeffrey, My name is Dory Gannes and, of course, I am a fan of your work - mostly because it allows me to stay connected to East Africa when I am not there. However, I am writing to you today to say more than thank you; I am writing to ask of your opinion of an interesting experience I had in Kenya a few weeks ago.
I have a small non-profit that primarily does work in a small village outside of Arusha, but got the opportunity to travel outside of Tanzania to Kenya with Farah Maalim, Deputy Speaker for Kenya's Parliament. Farah and I were both taking courses at the same school and he overheard me mention that I will be attending the Fletcher School of International Affairs this upcoming fall. Three hours of conversation later, he had invited me to come out to Kenya to see some of his development projects.
Though I didn't believe it would actually happen, the following weekend, we were flying out to Kenya and driving out of Nairobi accompanied by his wife (a doctor whom you might have heard of? Khadija Abdalla? She most recently was working at the main hospital in Garissa before the UN recognized her work and she received a fellowship to study public health at the University of Chicago?), daughter, and armored bodyguard. In between his interviews, phone calls, and speeches about the islamic radicals flooding in from Somalia - the same topic you covered in one of your photo stories before following Clinton around the continent - we visited five of his different projects within his constituency. The most interesting of which was the Millennium Village in Dertu.
Of course I realize that Jeffrey Sachs, or anyone else for that matter, isn't as godly as many people make him out to be. But for some reason, I was optimistic about his Millennium Village Project. I know development work is tough, foreign aid is a dubious topic, and some money inevitably will end up in pockets rather than with the local people; however, what I saw blew in Dertu my mind.
Supposedly 1 million dollars of aid has gone into this village - yet the village has only accounted for $125,000; the trees haven't been planted or watered and are dying in the scorching heat; the dispensary has no drugs left for the villagers; and the nurses and village members are instructed to throw their belongings in the closet and not speak when visitors arrive on their pre-planned visits. Only during these visits do directors and project managers appear and does the place look slightly similar to the fake picture highlighted on the website.
I am just getting into Sach's book to try and figure out what he was attempting to do when he put the project together so then maybe then I can begin to understand what the hell went wrong. The village, to say the least, is not a reproducible solution for combating poverty in developing countries.
I am not sure what could come out of this email but I feel slightly lost with what to do with my experience. The good news is that I will be moving to Boston in less than a week for my first year at Fletcher in the MALD program. The bad news is that I still feel unresolved about those few days I spent in Kenya -- well -- mostly I feel unresolved about the hour I spent at the Millennium Village in Dertu.
What do you think? Is this at all surprising to you? Or just another story of failed development work?
Sorry for the length of this. I really did try to cut it down and get to the point...
Hope we can connect.
Take care.